Are fake reviews illegal? What online store owners need to know
Are fake reviews illegal? What the US FTC rule and Saudi e-commerce law say about buying reviews, the business risks, and legitimate ways to get real ones.
Every new store hits the same wall: shoppers won't buy from a page with no reviews, and you can't get reviews without buyers. Services selling "50 five-star reviews" promise a shortcut. So, are fake reviews illegal? In a growing number of markets, yes. Even where the law is less explicit, they are a bad bet. This article covers what regulators say, with a focus on the US and Saudi Arabia, and what to do instead.
This is general information, not legal advice. For a specific situation, talk to a lawyer in your jurisdiction.
What counts as a fake review?
A fake review is any review that doesn't reflect a genuine experience, or that hides the writer's connection to the business. Common forms:
- Reviews written by the owner or staff under invented customer names.
- Reviews bought from a review-selling service.
- AI-generated reviews attributed to customers.
- Reviews from friends, family or employees without disclosure.
- Rewards given on condition that the review is positive.
- Suppressing real negative reviews through threats or pressure.
Are fake reviews illegal in the US?
On 14 August 2024 the US Federal Trade Commission announced a final rule banning fake reviews and testimonials (FTC press release). The rule prohibits:
- Creating, selling or buying fake reviews, including AI-generated ones, when the business knew or should have known they were fake.
- Offering compensation or incentives conditioned on writing a positive (or negative) review.
- Undisclosed reviews from company insiders.
- Company-controlled "independent" review sites.
- Suppressing reviews through groundless legal threats, intimidation or false accusations.
- Buying or selling fake social media indicators, like bot followers or views.
The FTC says the rule lets it seek civil penalties against knowing violators.
Are fake reviews illegal in Saudi Arabia?
Saudi Arabia's E-Commerce Law prohibits, in Article 11, including in an electronic advertisement any false offer, statement or claim, or wording that could directly or indirectly deceive or mislead the consumer. Reporting on enforcement of the law cites fines of up to SAR 1 million, plus blocking or closing the offending store and banning it from operating (Okaz, Arabic).
The article doesn't use the words "fake reviews". But a fabricated review displayed on a product page is, in substance, a misleading claim about the product, which is exactly what the provision targets. Saudi and Gulf merchants on platforms like Salla should treat bought reviews as a serious compliance risk, not a grey area.
Is buying fake reviews worth the risk? The business case
Even if nobody reports you, fake reviews cost you:
- Shoppers spot patterns. Twenty similar-sounding five-star reviews posted in the same week is a pattern experienced shoppers recognise.
- Perfection backfires. The Spiegel Research Center found that purchase likelihood typically peaks at average ratings of 4.0–4.7 and declines as ratings approach 5.0 (source).
- You lose the signal. Real reviews tell you about sizing, packaging and shipping problems. Bought ones tell you nothing.
- Trust doesn't come back. One screenshot of duplicated reviews travels faster than any ad campaign.
Legitimate ways to get your first reviews
- Ask every real customer, every time, after delivery. Templates are in how to ask customers for reviews.
- Reward the review, not the rating. Loyalty points for any honest review, positive or negative. Salla's loyalty system can award points for reviews.
- Seed with disclosure. If you give a product to a customer or creator, ask for an honest opinion and make sure the free product is disclosed.
- Start with your bestsellers. Get each key product to its first five reviews, since those carry the biggest lift.
- Show other trust signals meanwhile: a clear return policy, official business verification, recognised payment methods and real product photos. More in social proof in e-commerce.
Proof that is hard to fake
The hardest things to fabricate are sensory details: a photo of the product in a real home, an unboxing video, or a customer's own voice. On Salla you can allow customers to attach photos and videos to reviews. With Sawtk, a customer who has written a Salla review can add a short voice clip, with explicit consent to publish it. You approve every clip before it appears. Tone, pauses and genuine enthusiasm are very hard to fake and very easy to believe.
The bottom line
Fake reviews might save you a few weeks. In return they put your store in regulatory crosshairs, hide real feedback, and risk trust that took years to build. The slower path — asking every customer and rewarding honesty rather than stars — is the one that lasts.